In as long as mation Markets John Ledyard April 13, 2005 Nancy Schwartz Memorial Lecture

In as long as mation Markets John Ledyard April 13, 2005 Nancy Schwartz Memorial Lecture www.phwiki.com

In as long as mation Markets John Ledyard April 13, 2005 Nancy Schwartz Memorial Lecture

Cox, Sonya, Contributing Columnist has reference to this Academic Journal, PHwiki organized this Journal In as long as mation Markets John Ledyard April 13, 2005 Nancy Schwartz Memorial Lecture KGSM, Northwestern University What would you like to know What will Disney’s profits be in 2006 Ask an accountant, a stock analyst, a consultant, the CEO, Mickey Mouse, Who will the next Pope be Ask a pundit, a cardinal, take a poll, How stable will the middle-east be on 12/31/05 Ask the CIA, the Mossad, the Defense Department, the President, a committee of experts, . Should you set up an In as long as mation Market What is an In as long as mation Market This is not about markets as long as in as long as mation. Kihlstrom (1974), Radner in addition to Stiglitz (1984), Kamien in addition to Tauman (1990), Keppo, Moscarini, Smith (2005) It is about using market as long as ces to bring together disparate bits in addition to pieces of in as long as mation in addition to add them up, or aggregate them, as long as use in predictions or decisions. Google hits In as long as mation Markets = 25,700,000 Prediction Markets = 1,550,000

Academy of Hair Design-Salem OR www.phwiki.com

This Particular University is Related to this Particular Journal

How would it work Familiar Question: Who will win an election St in addition to ard approach – Polls. In 1988, University of Iowa Business School securitized the Presidential election prediction on the internet. The Iowa Election Market In 1992, as long as $1.00, Iowa sold or bought a set of securities that covered all possible outcomes of the election; Bush, Clinton, Other (included Perot). The Iowa Election Market In 1992, as long as $1.00, Iowa sold or bought a set of securities that covered all possible outcomes of the election; Bush, Clinton, Other (included Perot). Each security paid $1 times the percentage of the vote as long as that person. Securities were traded.

The Iowa Election Market In 1992, as long as $1.00, Iowa sold or bought a set of securities that covered all possible outcomes of the election; Bush, Clinton, Other (included Perot). Each security paid $1 times the percentage of the vote as long as that person. Securities were traded. After the election tally, if you owned 100 shares of Bush in addition to Bush received 38% of the vote then you would be paid $38. The Iowa Election Market In 1992, as long as $1.00, Iowa sold or bought a set of securities that covered all possible outcomes of the election; Bush, Clinton, Other (included Perot). Each security paid $1 times the percentage of the vote as long as that person. Securities were traded. After the election tally, if you owned 100 shares of Bush in addition to Bush received 38% of the vote then you would be paid $38. The actual result was Clinton 43%, Bush 38%, Perot 19% How the IEM might work. You go to the IEM website in addition to see You see a way to make some money.

How the IEM might work. How the IEM might work. How the IEM might work. You actually will make (0.38×2) – 1.10 = -$0.34. But you don’t know that when you make this transaction. You can only act on your beliefs.

How the IEM might work. Other traders then adjust their beliefs in response to the price changes. And so on. If all goes well, in equilibrium, prices will equate to the full-in as long as mation beliefs of the traders. And if all goes well, these will be the true vote-shares. 1992 U.S. Election Source: IEM (2005) How Accurate Has IEM Been Source: IEM (2005)

Also National election market in NY (1868-1940) [Rhode in addition to Strumpf (2004)] “Over $165 million (in 2002 dollars) was wagered in one election, in addition to betting activity at times dominated transactions in the stock exchanges on Wall Street.” “In only one case did the c in addition to idate clearly favored in the betting a month be as long as e Election Day lose.” Is this a Free Lunch Iowa pays nothing. On average, the traders earn nothing But, in the end, everyone is better, maybe even maximally, in as long as med. “The Next Killer App” or “Too Good To Be True” Evidence, mostly empirical, suggests In as long as mation Markets Work. Evidence, mostly theoretical, suggests In as long as mation Markets Can’t Work. Today we will explore how “In as long as mation Markets” work how to design in addition to engineer viable in addition to accurate “In as long as mation Mechanisms”

Why might an IM work There are two of us in this scenario. (Neither of us is a Game Theorist.) There are 2 coins: Coin A comes up heads 80% of the time. Coin B comes up heads 20% of the time. One is chosen with probability .5. This is our common prior. The coin is flipped twice as long as each of us. You see (H,T) in addition to I don’t see that. I see in addition to you don’t see that. Why might an IM work Remember: Coin A = .8 heads, Coin B = .2 heads, you see (H,T), I see (, ). What is the probability that the coin is A Based on only your in as long as mation, the answer is 0.5. This is your initial posterior. Suppose there is a Market Maker who posts prices in addition to asks us whether we want to buy or sell an asset that pays $1 if the coin is A in addition to $0 if it is B. He posts a price of 0.60. You offer to sell in addition to I offer to buy. Why might an IM work Remember: Coin A = .8 heads, Coin B = .2 heads, you see (H,T), I see (, ), I offered to buy at .6. What is the probability that the coin is A Since you know that I must have seen (H,H), you know (H,T,H,H). This is everything. Your answer should be 0.94. Of course, I only know that you are either (H,T) or (T,T), so I don’t know everything – yet.

Why might an IM work Suppose the Market Maker still posts a price of .6. We both offer to buy. I now know that your current posterior is .94 which means you must have seen (H,T) So we both now know that the total in as long as mation is (3H, 1T) in addition to our posteriors are the same: 0.94. The “market” has “aggregated” the “in as long as mation”! The underlying theories are Rational Expectations Equilibrium in addition to Common Knowledge In as long as mation. Green (1973), Lucas (1972), Grossman (1977) Aumann (1976), Geanakopolos in addition to Polemarchakis (1982) But Wait!!!! = Market Maker Maxwell’s Demon There is something fishy here! Why might an IM not work Let’s go back to the Market in addition to get rid of the Market Maker. Remember: Coin A = .8 heads, Coin B = .2 heads, you see (H,T), I see (, ), the asset pays $1 if A. I offer to sell you 2 units of the asset as long as .30. What should you do now Infer that I saw (T,T) in addition to believe (1 H, 3T). So you now should believe that P(A) = .06

Cox, Sonya MGW (Mom Guess What) Newspaper Contributing Columnist www.phwiki.com

Why might an IM not work I offer you 2 units of the asset as long as .30, you saw (H,T) in addition to know I saw (T,T), so your P(A) = .06. You believe the expected value of the asset is .06. Obviously you should reject my offer. The full in as long as mation is either (1H,3T) or (0H,4T). If you had seen (H,H) you would accept my offer. If you bid to buy above .004, I also know it is 0.6. We will not trade! The underlying theory is No-Trade Theorems [Grossman in addition to Stiglitz (1976), Milgrom-Stokey (1988)] What About Empirical Evidence There are many naturally occurring IM’s And, in direct comparisons, they beat other institutions. Pari-mutuel betting

Pari-mutuel betting Racetrack odds beat track experts Figlewski (1979) Futures markets Futures markets OJ futures improve freeze as long as ecasts Roll (1984)

= Market Maker Maxwell’s Demon Is the best mechanism MSR Is

Cox, Sonya Contributing Columnist

Cox, Sonya is from United States and they belong to MGW (Mom Guess What) Newspaper and they are from  Sacramento, United States got related to this Particular Journal. and Cox, Sonya deal with the subjects like Sexual Health

Journal Ratings by Academy of Hair Design-Salem

This Particular Journal got reviewed and rated by Academy of Hair Design-Salem and short form of this particular Institution is OR and gave this Journal an Excellent Rating.